Why Apologetics Is Failing—and What Augustine Knew That We Forgot

Modern apologetics is losing its grip on culture - but what if Augustine, writing during Rome’s collapse, already solved our biggest evangelism challenges?

April 30, 2025

Transcript Summary

In this episode of The Remnant Radio, Joshua Lewis hosts scholars Dr. Josh Chatraw and Dr. Mark D. Allen to discuss the challenges of evangelism in the Western world and explore how the theological insights of Augustine can inform a more effective approach. The conversation begins by acknowledging the perceived disconnect between traditional apologetic methods and their limited success in reaching contemporary audiences. The team questions why apologetics seem broken in the West.

The discussion then pivots to the concept of “cultural apologetics,” emphasizing the importance of understanding the cultural context and social imaginary that shapes people’s beliefs and values. The guests explain how Augustine, as a pastor and theologian in a period of cultural upheaval, offers a valuable model for engaging with a pluralistic and often skeptical world. The team dives into this time of great upheaval.

Josh Chatraw  and Mark Allen highlight the need to move beyond a purely rationalistic approach to apologetics, recognizing that humans are not simply “brains on sticks” but complex beings driven by desires, affections, and deeply held beliefs. They advocate for a more relational and empathetic approach, one that seeks to understand people’s stories and to connect the Gospel to their deepest longings.

The conversation also explores the importance of grounding apologetics in the local church and allowing the life of the Christian community to serve as a witness to the transformative power of the Gospel. Remnant host Joshua Lewis emphasizes that apologetics shouldn’t be confined to academic debates or online arguments but should be integrated into the fabric of everyday life, with Christians embodying the love, grace, and truth of Christ in their interactions with others.

Share